Method of Improving Stability of a Highly-Loaded Axial Compressor Stage by Coupling Different Casing Treatments

Document Type : Regular Article


School of Power and Energy, Northwestern Polytechnical University,Xi'an,Shaanxi,710072,China



Casing treatment is a powerful method for improving the stability of aircraft compressors. An optimized slot-type casing treatment was tested on the first rotor of a highly-loaded two-stage compressor, and the results showed that the casing treatment could not increase the compressor stability at the design and off-design speeds. A coupled casing treatment (CCT), which is built with an injector, a bridge, a plenum chamber, and several slots for a recirculating loop, is proposed and optimized to enhance the stability of the compressor in the present study. The optimized CCT improves the compressor stability and efficiency under the design condition by 75.8% and 0.71%, respectively. The coupling effect, which is established with an inner circulation in the slots and an outer circulation from the slots to the injectors, accounts for the excellent stability enhancement. The coupling effect reduces the amount of tip leakage flow, depresses the development of the tip leakage vortex (TLV), and greatly decreases the blockage in the rotor tip which is primarily induced by the interaction of the shock-wave and boundary-layer at the blade suction surface. The parametric study shows that improving the coupling effect has a positive effect on reducing the rotor tip blockage, but a negative effect on the stability of the compressor stage. This is because the inflow condition of the stator is tremendously distorted while the coupling effect is excessively strong, which can cause a stall in the stator rather than in the rotor. The compressor stability can be maximally enhanced by adjusting the strength of the coupling effect to make a compromise of the improved rotor tip flow and the deteriorated stator flow.


Alone D. B., Kumar S. S., Shobhavathy M. T., Mudipalli J. R. R., Pradeep A. M., Ramamurthy S., Venkat S. I. (2017). Experimental assessment on effect of lower porosities of bend skewed casing treatment on the performance of high-speed compressor stage with tip critical rotor characteristics. Aerospace Science and Technology 60,193-202.##
Brignole, G. A., Danner F. C. T and H. P. Kau (2008). Time resolved simulation and experimental validation of the flow in axial slot casing treatments for transonic axial compressors. ASME Turbo Expo 2008:Berlin,Germany, 363-374.##
Cheng, P., M. E. Prell, E. M. Greitzer and C. S. Tan (1984). Effects of Compressor Hub Treatment on Stator Stall and Pressure Rise. AIAA Journal of Aircraft 21 (7),469–475.##
Cumpsty, N. A. (1989). Part-circumference casing treatment and the effect on compressor stall.  ASME Turbo Expo 1989. American Society of Mechanical Engineers.##
Denton, J. D. (1993). Loss Mechanisms in Turbomachines. Journal of Turbomachinery 115(4), 621-656.##
Dinh, C. T, M. W. Heo and K. Y. Kim (2015). Aerodynamic performance of transonic axial compressor with a casing groove combined with blade tip injection and ejection. Aerospace Science and Technology 46,176-187.##
Epstein, A. H. (1985).  'Smart' engine components - A micro in every blade. AIAA Paper AIAA-85-1296.##
Fujita, H. and H. Takata (1987). A Study on Configurations of Casing Treatment for Axial Flow Compressors. Bulletin of the JSME  27 (230) ,1675-1681.##
Goinis, G., V. Christian and A. Marcel (2013).  Automated optimization of an axial-slot type casing treatment for a transonic compressor. ASME Turbo Expo 2013. Turbine Technical Conference and Exposition.##
Greitzer, E. M., J. P. Nikkanen, D. E. Haddad, R. S. Mazzawy and H. D. Joslyn (1979). A Fundamental Criterion for the Application of Rotor Casing Treatment. Journal of Fluids Engineering 101(2), 237–243.##
Hah, C. (2015). Effects of Unsteady Flow Interactions on the Performance of a Highly-loaded Transonic Compressor Stage. ASME Turbo Expo 2015, Turbine Technical Conference and Exposition.##
Hah, C. (2019). The inner workings of axial casing grooves in a one and a half stage axial compressor with a large rotor tip gap: Changes in stall margin and efficiency. Journal of Turbomachinery 141(1),1-16.##
Halawa, T., M. Alqaradawi, O. Badr and M. S. Gadala (2015). Numerical simulation of using combined active and passive stall control techniques in centrifugal compressors. ASME 2014 International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition, IMECE2014-37983.##
Hathaway, M. D. (2007). Passive Endwall Treatments for Enhancing Stability. NASA Technical Paper TR-3878.##
He, X. and X. Zheng (2019). Roles and mechanisms of casing treatment on different scales of flow instability in high pressure ratio centrifugal compressors. Aerospace Science and Technology 84, 734-746.##
Heinichen, F., V. Gummer and H. P. Schiffer (2011). Numerical Investigation of a Single Circumferential Groove Casing Treatment on Three Different Compressor Rotors. ASME  Turbo Expo, Turbine Technical Conference and Exposition.##
Hiller, S. J., R. Matzgeller and W. Horn (2011). Stability enhancement of a multistage compressor by air injection. Journal of Turbomachinery 133(3),031009-1- 031009-7.##
Li, J., F. Lin, Z. Tong, C. Nie and J. Chen (2015).The Dual Mechanisms and Implementations of Stability Enhancement with Discrete Tip Injection in Axial Flow Compressors. Journal of Turbomachinery 137(3),031010-1~031010-10.##
Lin, A., Y. Sun, H. Zhang, X. Lin and Lu. Yang (2018). Fluctuating characteristics of air-mist mixture flow with conjugate wall-film motion in a compressor of gas turbine. Applied Thermal Engineering 142, 779-792.##
Lin, A., Q. Zheng, Y. Jiang, X. Lin and H. Zhang (2019). Sensitivity of air/mist non-equilibrium phase transition cooling to transient characteristics in a compressor of gas turbine. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 137, 882-894.##
Lin A. Q., Liu G. W., Chen Y., Feng Q., Zhang H. (2021a). Evaluation and analysis of evaporation cooling on thermodynamic and pressure characteristics of intake air in a precooled turbine engine. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 46(47), 24410-24424.##
Lin, A., G. Liu, X. Wang and Q. Feng (2021b). Comprehensive evaluations on performance and energy consumption of pre-swirl rotor–stator system in gas turbine engines. Energy Conversion and Management 244, 114440.##
Liu, G., W. Gong, H. Wu, L. Pang, A. Lin (2021a). Theoretical and experimental evaluation of temperature drop and power consumption in a cover-plate pre-swirl system for gas turbine cooling. Case Studies in Thermal Engineering 27, 101221.##
Liu, G., X. Wang, W. Gong and A. Lin (2021b). Prediction of the sealing flow effect on the temperature drop characteristics of a pre-swirl system in an aero-engine. Applied Thermal Engineering 189, 116717.##
Liu, G., W. Gong, H. Wu and A. Lin (2021-c). Experimental and CFD analysis on the pressure ratio and entropy increment in a cover-plate pre-swirl system of gas turbine engine. Engineering Applications of Computational Fluid Mechanics 15(1), 476-489.##
Lu, X., W. Chu, Y. Zhang and J. Zhu (2006). Experimental and numerical investigation of a subsonic compressor with bend-skewed slot-casing treatment. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part C: Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science 220 (12),1785-1796.##
Lu, X., W. Chu and J. Zhu (2007). Numerical investigations of the flow mechanisms in a subsonic compressor rotor with axial-skewed slot. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part A: Journal of Power and Energy 221 (3),301-313.##
Lurie, D. P. and A. Breeze-Stringfellow (2015).  Evaluation of Experimental Data From a Highly Loaded Transonic Compressor Stage to Determine Loss Sources. ASME Turbo Expo 2015, Turbine Technical Conference and Exposition.##
Mileshin, V. I., A. M. Petrovitchev and V. V.  Zhdanov (2018). Numerical and experimental investigation as applied to effects of labyrinth-type casing treatments on performance of high-loaded compressor first stage. ASME Turbo Expo, Turbomachinery Technical Conference and Exposition.##
Rolfes, M., M. Lange, K. Vogeler and R. Mailach (2017). Experimental and Numerical Investigation of a Circumferential Groove Casing Treatment in a Low Speed Axial Research Compressor at Different Tip Clearances. ASME Turbo Expo, Turbomachinery Technical Conference and Exposition.##
Schnell, R., M. Voges, R. Monig, M. W. Muller and C. Zscherp (2011). Investigation of blade tip interaction with casing treatment in a transonic compressor-part II: Numerical results. Journal of Turbomachinery 133 (1),011008-1~011008-11.##
Shabbir, A. and J. J. Adamczyk (2005). Flow Mechanism for Stall Margin Improvement due to Circumferential Casing Grooves on Axial Compressors. Journal of Turbomachinery 127(4), 708-717.##
Suder, K. L., M. D. Hathaway, S. A. Thorp, A. J. Strazisar and MB. Bright (2000.).  Compressor Stability Enhancement Using Discrete Tip Injection. ASME Turbo Expo, Power for Land, Sea, and Air.##
Sun, D., J. Li, X. Dong, B. Gu and X. Sun (2018). Effects of Rotating Inlet Distortion on Two-Stage Compressor Stability with Stall Precursor-Suppressed Casing Treatment. ASME Turbo Expo, Turbomachinery Technical Conference and Exposition.##
Sun, X., D. Xu and D. Sun (2019). Recent development of casing treatments for aero-engine compressors. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics 32 (1), 1-36.##
Taghavi-Zenouz R., Behbahani M. H. A. (2018). Improvement of aerodynamic performance of a low speed axial compressor rotor blade row through air injection. Aerospace Science and Technology 72, 409-417.##
Voges, M., C. Willert, R. Monig and H. P. Schiffer (2013).  The effect of a bend-slot casing treatment on the blade tip flow field of a transonic compressor rotor. ASME Turbo Expo 2013, Turbine Technical Conference and Exposition.##
Wang, W., J. Lu, X. Luo and W. Chu (2020). Failure mechanism of slot casing treatment in improving stability of a Highly-Loaded Axial Compressor Stage. Aerospace Science and Technology 105, 105979.##
Wang, W., W. Chu and H. Zhang (2014). The effect of injector size on compressor performance in transonic axial compressor with discrete tip injection. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part A: Journal of Power and Energy 228 (7),760-771.##
Wang, W., W. Chu and H. Zhang (2015). Numerical investigation on the effect of a plenum chamber with slot-type casing treatment on the performance of an axial transonic compressor. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part A: Journal of Power and Energy 229 (4),393–405.##
Wang, W., W. Chu and H. Zhang (2018). Mechanism study of performance enhancement in a subsonic axial flow compressor with recirculating casing treatment. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part G: Journal of Aerospace Engineering 232(4),680-693.##
Wang, W., W. Chu, H. Zhang and H. Kuang (2017). Experimental and numerical study of tip injection in a subsonic axial flow compressor. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics 30 (3),907-917.##
Wang, W., J. Lu, X. Luo and W. Chu (2019). Coupling Method of Stability Enhancement Based on Casing Treatments in an Axial Compressor. Aerospace Science and Technology 95 (105449),1-13.##
Wilke, I., H. P. Kau and G. Brignole (2005). Numerically Aided Design of a High-efficient Casing Treatment for a Transonic Compressor. ASME Turbo Expo 2005, Gas Turbie Technology.##
Yang, L., Q. Zheng, A. Lin and M. Luo (2020). Unsteady performance and thermodynamic analysis of aero-engine compressor at different water ingestion conditions. International Journal of Energy Research 44(8), 6567-6582.##
Zhang, H., Y. Wu, Y. Li, X. Yu and B. Liu (2019). Control of compressor tip leakage flow using plasma actuation. Aerospace Science and Technology 86,244-255.##