Parameter-Based Design and Analysis of Wind Turbine Airfoils with Conformal Slot Co-Flow Jet

Document Type : Regular Article


National Key Laboratory of Science and Technology on Aerodynamic Design and Research, Northwestern Polytechnical University, Xi'an, 710072, China



A co-flow jet (CFJ), an active flow control method combining blowing and suction control, can effectively suppress the stall of airfoils. However, the streamwise jet channel along the upper surface of a conventional CFJ airfoil reduces the thickness and camber of the baseline, degrading the aerodynamic performance when the jet is inactive. The conformal slot CFJ airfoil was proposed to address this problem, but the design method is still absent. This paper proposed a general design method based on parameters including the slot angle, transition shape and distance of the injection and suction slot. The mechanism of the best parameter was analyzed. The designed conformal slot CFJ airfoil was checked under different jet intensities, and the turbine power curve was predicted when substituting CFJ airfoils for the baseline. Compared with the conventional CFJ airfoil, the designed conformal slot CFJ airfoil has three advantages: eliminating the performance loss when the jet is off, saving jet energy when suppressing the flow separation, and improving the power generation of wind turbines at low wind speeds.


Aramendia, I., U. Fernández-Gámiz, J. Ramos-Hernanz, J. Sancho, J. M. López-Guede and E. Zulueta (2017). Flow Control Devices for Wind Turbines. In: Bizon, N., Mahdavi Tabatabaei, N., Blaabjerg, F., Kurt, E. (2017). Flow Control Devices for Wind Turbines. In: Bizon, N., Mahdavi Tabatabaei, N., Blaabjerg, F., Kurt, E. (eds) Energy Harvesting and Energy Efficiency. Lecture Notes in Energy, vol 37. Springer, Cham, Switzerland.##
Aubrun, S., A. Leroy and P. Devinant (2017). A review of wind turbine-oriented active flow control strategies. Experiments in Fluids 58(9), 1-21.##
Boling J. S. and G. C. Zha (2021, January). Numerical investigation of longitudinal static stability of a high-speed tandem-wing VTOL vehicle using co-flow jet airfoil. In AIAA SciTech 2021 Forum, Virtual event.##
Byrd, C. S., M. Emmanuel, D. O. Velardo, D. Stone and Wang, W. (2021, January). Conceptual design of a high endurance rotating-wing mars exploration spacecraft(HERMES). In AIAA SciTech 2021 Forum, Virtual event.##
Car, D., N. J. Kuprowicz, J. Estevadeordal, Zha G. C. and W. Copenhaver (2004, June). Stator Diffusion Enhancement Using a Re-Circulating Co-Flowing Steady Jet. In Proceeding of Asme Turbo Expo 2004, Vienna, Austria.##
Chng, T. L., J. M. Zhang and H. M. Tsai (2008, January). A novel method of flow injection and suction for lift enhancement. In 46th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit, Reno, United States.##
Choudhry, A., M. Arjomandi and R. Kelso (2013). Horizontal axis wind turbine dynamic stall predictions based on wind speed and direction variability. Proceeding of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part A: Journal of Power and Energy 227(3), 338-351.##
Dhakal, S., Y. C. Yang, G. C. Zha and J. Boiling (2017, June). Numerical investigation of low speed performance of transonic co-flow jet airfoil. In 35th AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference, Denver, United States.##
Fan, Z. X. and C. C. Zhu (2019). The optimization and the application for the wind turbine power-wind speed curve. Renewable Energy 140(9), 52-61.##
Gad-el-Hak, M. (2000). Flow Control: Passive, Active, and Reactive Flow Management. Cambridge University Press, Cambs, Britain.##
Genç, M. S., U. Kaynak and H. Yapici (2011).  Performance of transition model for predicting low Re aerofoil flows without/with single and simultaneous blowing and suction. European Journal of Mechanics B-fluids 30(3), 218-235.##
International Energy Agency (2021). World Energy Outlook 2021. Report of International Energy Agency. Paris, France.##
Johnson, S. J., J. P. Baker, V. C. P. Dam and D. Berg (2010). An overview of active load control techniques for wind turbines with an emphasis on microtabs. Wind Energy 13(3), 239-253.##
Johnston, J. P. and M. Nishi (1990). Vortex generator jets - Means for flow separation control. AIAA Journal 28(6), 989-994.##
Laval, J. P., C. Braud, G. Fournier and M. Stanislas (2010). Large-eddy simulations of control of a separated flow over a 2D bump by means of pulsed jets. Journal of Turbulence 11(11), 1-33.##
Lefebvre, A. and G. C. Zha (2013, January). Numerical Simulation of Pitching Airfoil Performance Enhancement Using Co-Flow Jet Flow Control. In 31st AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference, San Diego, United States.##
Lefebvre, A. and G. C. Zha (2014, January). Pitching Airfoil Performance Enhancement Using Co-Flow Jet Flow Control at High Mach Number. In 52nd Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Maryland, United States.##
Liu, J., R. Chen and R. Qiu and W. Zhang (2020). Study on dynamic stall control of rotor airfoil based on coflow jet. International Journal of Aerospace Engineering 2020(8845924), 1-15.##
Liu, J., R. Chen and Q. Song and Z. Shi (2022a). Active flow control of helicopter rotor based on coflow jet. International Journal of Aerospace Engineering 2022(9299470), 1-19.##
Liu, J., R. Chen and Y. You and Z. Shi (2022b). Numerical investigation of dynamic stall suppression of rotor airfoil via improved co-flow jet. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics 35(3), 169-184.##
Liu, Z. X. and G. C. Zha (2016, June). Transonic airfoil performance enhancement using co-flow jet active flow control. In 8th AIAA Flow Control Conference, Washington, D. C.. United States.##
Mamouri, A. R., E. Lakzian and A. B. Khoshnevis (2019). Entropy analysis of pitching airfoil for offshore wind turbines in the dynamic stall condition. Ocean Engineering 187(9), 106229.1-106229.19.##
Prince, S. A., C. Badalamenti and C. Regas (2017). The application of passive air jet vortex-generators to stall suppression on wind turbine blades. Wind Energy 20(1), 109-123.##
Rafiuddin, N., M. Y. Saif and A. Ahmad (2018, Sept). Wind Array: A novel approach to low speed wind harnessing. In 2018 International Conference on Computing, Power and Communication Technologies (Gucon), Greater Noida, India.##
Shun, S. and N. A. Ahmed (2012). Wind Turbine Performance Improvements using Active Flow Control Techniques. Procedia Engineering 49(10), 83-91.##
Singh, R. K. and M. R. Ahmed (2013). Blade design and performance testing of a small wind turbine rotor for low wind speed applications. Renewable Energy 50(8), 812-819.##
Somers, D. M. (1997). Design and experimental results for the S809 airfoil. NREL/SR-440-6918, the National Renewable Energy Laboratory. Fort Collins, United States.##
Van Dam, C. P., D. E. Berg and S. J. Johnson (2008). Active Load Control Techniques for Wind Turbines. SAND2008-4809, the Sandia National Laboratiries, Albuquerque, United States.##
Wang, Y. and G. C. Zha (2019, June). Study of super-lift coefficient of co-flow jet airfoil and its power consumption. In AIAA Aviation 2019 Forum, Dallas, United States.##
Wu, T., B. F. Song, W. P. Song, W. Q. Yang and Z. H. Han (2020). Aerodynamic performance enhancement for flapping airfoils by co-flow jet. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics 33(10), 2535-2554.##
Xu, H. Y., C. L. Qiao and Z. Y. Ye (2016). Dynamic Stall Control on the Wind Turbine Airfoil via a Co-Flow Jet. Energies 9(6), 429.1-429.25.##
Xu, H. Y., S. L. Xing and Z. Y. Ye (2015). Numerical study of the S809 airfoil aerodynamic performance using a co-flow jet active control concept. Journal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy 7(2), 023131.1- 023131. 21.##
Xu, K. W. and G. C. Zha (2020, June). Investigation of Coflow Jet Active Flow Control for Wind Turbine. In AIAA Aviation 2020 FORUM, Virtual Event.##
Xu, K. W. and G. C. Zha (2021, June). High efficiency wind turbine using co-flow jet active flow control. In Proceedings of ASME Turbo Expo 2021, Virtual event.##
Xu, K. W., J. H. Zhang and G. C. Zha (2019, January). Drag minimization of co-flow jet control surfaces at cruise conditions. In AIAA Scitech 2019 Forum, San Diego, United States.##
Yang, Y. C. and G. C. Zha (2017, January). Super-lift coefficient of active flow control airfoil: what is the limit?. In 55th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Grapevine, United States.##
Yang, Y. C. and G. C. Zha (2018, January). Numerical investigation of ultra-high lift coefficient co-flow jet flow control wing. In 2018 AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Kissimmee, United States.##
Yang, Y. C. and G. C. Zha (2018, June). Numerical investigation of performance improvement of the co-flow jet electric airplane. In 2018 Applied Aerodynamics Conference, Atlanta, United Stated.##
Yang, Y. C. and G. C. Zha (2019, January). Conceptual design of the co-flow jet hybrid electric regional airplane. In AIAA SciTech 2019 Forum, San Diego, United Stated.##
Zha, G. C. and B. F. Carroll, C. D. Paxton, C. Conley and A. P. Wells (2007). High-Performance Airfoil Using Coflow Jet Flow Control. AIAA Journal 45(8), 2087-2090.##
Zha, G. C., C. D. Paxton and C. Gables (2004, July). A Novel Airfoil Circulation Augment Flow Control Method Using Co-Flow Jet. In 2nd AIAA Flow Control Conference, Portland, United States.##
Zha, G. C., C. D. Paxton, A. P. Wells and B. F. Carroll (2006).  Effect of Injection Slot Size on the Performance of Coflow Jet Airfoil. Journal of Aircraft 43(4), 987-995.##
Zhang, J. M., T. L. Chng and H. M. Tsai (2011).  Performance of Coflow Jet Airfoils with Conformal Slot Geometries. Journal of Aircraft 48(3), 1107-1112.##
Zhang, X. L., X. D. Yang and B. F. Song (2021a).  Numerical investigation of performance enhancement of the S809 airfoil and phase VI wind turbine blade using co-flow jet technology. Energies 14(10), 6933.1-6933.20.##
Zhang, Y. Z., H. Y. Xu, Y. W. Chu and Y. Xu (2021b). Two-Dimensional Numerical Study of the Pulsed Co-Flow Jet. Fluid Dynamics 56(6):361-370.##
Zhi, H. L., Z. H. Zhu, Y. L. Lu, S. Deng and T. Xiao (2021). Aerodynamic performance enhancement of co-flow jet airfoil with simple high-lift device. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics 34(9), 143-155.##
Zhu, C. Y., Y. N. Qiu and T. G. Wang (2021). Dynamic stall of the wind turbine airfoil and blade undergoing pitch oscillations: A comparative study. Energy 222(5), 120004.1-120004.14.##
Volume 16, Issue 2 - Serial Number 70
February 2023
Pages 269-283
  • Received: 23 May 2022
  • Revised: 14 September 2022
  • Accepted: 27 September 2022
  • First Publish Date: 01 February 2023